Onlyreon
Sage_of_Eyes from patreon
Sage_of_Eyes patreon

Yellow Jacket: Chapter 3

🕑 Added 2018-02-16 06:25:38 +0000 UTC

Comments

SEEQYR

Ok, I figured something out, re: the voice of Taylor and why it sounds a lot like Hachiman. It's the "adverbs", and the overall tone of the fic. You're writing in the very specific format and subject-object-verb order of LN translation, which on its own is fine (but different to pure American English writing - and arguable to be okay here since this is "technically" a fusion/crossover if you were aiming for that, although if it was actually an intentional THING it could either be lampshaded at some point early on, or could fight back and forth with the sentence construction of Worm). The problem is, you're ALSO using the constructs of Oregairu, which is already stylistically different from other LNs, because of the "frequency" of the adverbs/interjections (see: Kyon from Haruhi vs Hachiman). That is: "Naturally, I went about my business." "Unexpectedly, I jumped higher." "Well, as always..." Those are Hachiman-isms, and Taylor doesn't HAVE them, because although she IS cynical and jaded, she's not THAT specific type of jaded. And for people who I think have never read LNs before, it's highly, highly jarring. Completely different writing style. It's also what you mentioned, in that it's sharply blocked off by Taylor. Everything is within Taylor's purview - even her doing research with wide sweeping consequences is denoted by "I'd done my research, and X". In my opinion, the first paragraph is pretty good Taylor. The second paragraph wavers, from the sentence of "...simply perfect", which is a combination of the adverb and the viewpoint change, from first person limited to third-person omniscient. It skips Taylor logic entirely. Also as a general note cause I'm running out of time - I could be reading Worm wrong, but Taylor - even when being Khepri (Speck 30.7) RARELY expresses more than one thought per sentence. Even when controlling millions of things at once, everything is dead straight and pointed. She doesn't get distracted, she just focuses harder. Which is part of the reason of the "Queen of Escalation" jokes, because she's got HORRIBLE amounts of tunnel vision. Despite being a multitasker extraordinaire because of her shard. In some of the sentences here, the POV drifts from thought to thought. In Worm, even when they're describing multiple things, all of them culminate in one purpose. You could read symbolism into that. But it's a very direct way of writing. Even when Wildbow hides things outside of that field of view. Hachiman is the direct opposite of that in a way. He hides things WITHIN the sentences. Or the space between sentences. Okay, that's all. (--Cetus)

Sage_Of_Eyes

I've been reading worm from a more analytic standpoint over the course of the week. From what I can tell, it's a more narrow, forced perspective via Taylor, with an emphasis on passive narration of the situation. I'll do my best to capture that in the following updates, to bring some fidelity to the crossover section.

Gopher54

Never read Worm, but definitely enjoying this. Taylor is making for an excellent contrast to the class of 1-A.

Sivantic

Maybe once it is public you can point out the parts that did sound like Taylor and use that to show the OOC parts. Otherwise, it is a bit annoying to see you complain on every Worm post and not offer usable advice. If it bothers you that much, just stop reading.

Rash

As much it is amusing take of Taylor, the feel of the character make me think more of Hachiman. From your Trandism fic. Amusing but not the right "voice".

BFldyq

I really wish I could be more help/I had the skills and awareness to properly identify what was wrong. I don't like that I can't offer you something more constructive then "this isn't right".

BFldyq

Less dramatically, I've said this before, but this doesn't read like Taylor at all. There are moments which are definitely Taylor-ish, but everything else seems *wrong*, especially her "voice".

BFldyq

Please, Sage. Stop writing Taylor. It's painful. ;~;


More Creators