Onlyreon
simonshen from patreon
simonshen patreon

【讀者分享:美國大選特輯🇺🇸】 支持侵侵的心路歷程:從一而終的反共抗獨裁

🕑 Added 2024-11-05 09:01:11 +0000 UTC
【讀者分享:美國大選特輯🇺🇸】 支持侵侵的心路歷程:從一而終的反共抗獨裁

Comments

INH

即係唔係話沈教授po出嚟就代表你自己endorse,亦都同意應該有唔同觀點,但係係咪應該都審下稿先呢?比呢位人兄更加有條理、有道理嘅侵粉大有人在。單係見到成篇文loop N次嘅「社會主義法西斯」呢串newspeak已經唔明點解呢篇文po得出嚟

堅離地書院 College

大家咁熱烈,遲啲可能會寫一篇關於呢篇文章的個人閱讀感想 😅

悉尼 袋鼠

Simon嘅開場白好重要。 解釋刊登文章志在提供回音牆另外聲音。呢度唔係公海,大家知道刊登原因,就無以下我提出嘅情況。 不過Twitter已經睇好多,香港KOL聽好多,仲要以年計,無細讀。 MSM為咗 『平衡觀點』,都會直接報導、直播雙方當事人講話,主持亦唔會即場核實,因為以前都知道潛規則,頂多另跨大,但唔會講大話,個別立場就留返評論節目分析。 問題係過去8年,好多人唔再理會呢啲潛規則,而傳媒好一段時間唔即場矯正,變相成為disinformation參與者。

EY

沈教授有容乃大,海納百川👍🏽 雖然小弟才疏只能睇到文章8、9成,仍然非常感激教授登呢遍文章🙏🏽

yuki_hk__

Can’t believe writing with such quality can be posted here …

HK Glory

多謝教授安排!多謝Trump粉分享!希望大家唔好爭咬。向前看。

Carl Yang

說到內容爭議,當然不是單指立塲觀點。若只是立塲觀點分享,又何以令人敬佩呢。 敬佩當然是因為為了做對的事,做了別人所不會做的事。

pp lam

聯邦政府有權改到呢啲嗎?

Gary Au

恭喜侵侵勝選 , 啲人情何以堪

HO Wong

雖然文章中好多事件嘅是是非非我無本事分辨到;但字裡行間表達嘅價值觀,我buy! 樓上有師兄提到基督教精神同無神論。其實基督教精神對美國嘅重要性有好多大家談論過;許倬雲先生認為:美國最大嘅危機就係基督教精神萎縮。 一個人為咗俗世嘅正義、自由等願意犧牲,就係我所理解嘅基督教精神;同是否信教係無關嘅。

Good Year

有就美國2黨制, 限制左民主. 因為選擇資源太集中結構非常彊化, 但觀符Trump 既出現, 體現左現代既2 黨制 既所謂"黨"一樣會因為選票改變而改變路線, 其實係唔係對" 2黨制箝制左民主" 既回應呢? 以前既民主黨, 共和黨又多次改變就話離現代好遠, 但TRUMP係大家眼下出現既, 利害

lyk

One way to explain the fact that polarisation in this election goes way beyond eligible voters is using identities. What starts as interests and opinions becomes identity when it is socialised into a community, and we have more identities that we feel strongly about than anyone ever imagined. These identities are mostly dormant but get activated when threatened. When one member of the group is attacked, the whole group feels threatened. When choices in the media are few, the incentives of the media are not to offend anyone, in social media the opposite works. Social media does not just reflect, it also creates. Recommendation algorithms biased towards the loud, outrageous, colourful, inspirational and confrontational keeps our identities activated minute to minute. Now you have the political elite themselves also getting their reality feed from social media and wrapped around in a cocoon, who in turn weaponises this polarisation, as it is much easier to organise people against something than it is to unit a group of people on affirmative action. Now the self-reinforcing loop is complete, we are stuck in this state of polarisation in the US and beyond.

Circle8090

我覺得頗代表到普遍撐侵嘅港人立場

Vikki Wong

"恢復美國立國初衷以基督精神實施憲法共和"<-睇完依句已經可以收皮,美國超過一半人士話自己係無神論者

Emily Tam

Totally agree

K Wong

What I meant was the quality of his writing not his viewpoint.

Carl Yang

呢個就係我敬重教授之處。為咗做對的事(提供各種觀點),明知內容爭議依然刋登。為的是我們讀者仍有機會看到各種觀點,有機會理性討論

Chris

究竟呢篇文章有幾代表香港(2019黃絲) 支持trump 嘅人

Gary Au

我信, 一定有問題, 肯定背後有人做野, 今年連有錢佬都頂唔順民主黨 , 係時候換人撥亂反正

Gary Au

乜咁都比佢登.... 我以為唔支持賀大媽, 呢到會退款趕我走

Polly Yuen

反共抗獨裁?笑話!!! 侵侵最崇拜普京同習近平想點就點!😂

Polly Yuen

可惜如今嘅共和黨已經被攪個人崇拜嘅MAGA佔領!我寜願俾人畜無害嘅民主黨坐多4年,期待下屆共和黨搵返啲傳統精英, 如蓬佩奧, 我即刻支持!

Polly Yuen

希望大家認清事實,切勿道聽途說。誰人再說侵侵的眾多案件是政治迫害,就是對美國民主體系司法獨立的侮辱! 民主黨太軟弱同左膠係唔抵爭,但如果因此而選返侵來玩轉呢個世界,be careful what you’re wishing for!

Gary Au

而家美國比敗登搞到好幸福, 零元購, 坐監可以免費變性, 學校要教小學生變性, 打機變晒DEI , 係時候比侵侵返來撥亂反正

WL

嘗試讀畢全文,最終都放棄了

卡路士

感謝文章, 但係侵侵真係好兩極. 我在 tw, 同不同人討厭過侵侵, 我的感覺係, 好多西歐國人(美/英/法/德) 好L L L L L 憎侵侵, 哈哈, 但係我地HK TW 對侵侵又無咁抗拒, 認為佢無咁假, 所以佢輸我又唔係好意外, Haters 真係唔少. 到今年, 我和來自英國的朋友交談, 他們都認為侵侵上場, 都打杖, 哈哈哈. 其實我的角度係, 要現在都打緊. 所以, 只能說..will see..... 但係侵侵佢有仆街, 但係佢個班底, 點都吸引過民主黨那邊. 哈哈哈

K Wong

I'm surprised Mr. Shen bothered to ask this person to write his/her opinion. Even more surprised he put it up on his Patroen page.

Siu

我想睇啲有少少水準嘅文筆。好似以前建制派起碼有曾鈺成寫啲高級詭辯迫你認真思考。呢篇完全唔入流。

lyk

This election had been one heck of an education on social psychology. And btw, studies find that “neither group responded to exposure to the other side by moderating its own views… hearing contrary opinions drove partisans not just to a deeper certainty in the rightness of their cause, but more polarized policy positions”. The good news is there is evidence that structuring “positive, collaborative interactions” can promote understanding, but there is not a ton of incentives out there to bring that into being. (Why We Are Polarized - Ezra Klein)

pp lam

Thanks for share. Pretty much summarised the thought of all trump supporters 👍🏻 睇下大舊議員會唔會寫返千字文反駁🤣 個人意見,遠離西方盟友單打獨鬥,對俄羅斯同中國都係利大於弊

Chapman Yeung

如果唔係教授嘅開場白,我應該睇唔到去第二段....

dave

一定唔會有 Pompeo. 佢係Trump心目中就係 deep state, 傳統精英。

carl mak

我諗侵侵都要返主流派在參眾兩院發力支持,又唔會完全無主流派人仕在政府,但有幾多人就呢⋯⋯

Good Year

不論佢勝負, 佢係將極左, 溝返D極右, 係拉返中間DD既

Gary Lee

@carl mak: 如果冇主流派背書侵都贏到,我又唔覺得侵需要佢地

堅離地書院 College

上屆班子基本上都係共和黨右翼主流派,龐貝奧 馬蒂斯 凱勒 全部好decent 新班子係可以好偏,特別係如果有 Elon Musk 同 RFK Jr

carl mak

呢樣嘢都係侵侵回朝的一個隱憂,個人希望最少龐貝奧可以一齊回朝,做返侵侵個剎車掣

Gary Lee

呢篇文令我諗起一樣野。想當初 2016 年特朗普當選,入主白宮頭兩年同習近平金正恩傾偈,遠離西方傳統盟友。及後龐貝奧角色漸重,才嘗試將形勢拉返近。現今若果侵再當選,但身邊近西方班臣子都好似話同侵割左蓆,再加上全世界右翼主義枱頭,自己顧自己。未來四年美國同西方關係會變成點呢? P.S. 純粹好奇,好想知呢篇文係咪龔教授手筆 :)

edh0e

honestly, what the f##% did I just read?


More Creators