Onlyreon
EmmaLeia from patreon
EmmaLeia patreon

Scrapped Chapter

🕑 Added 2021-10-17 00:33:58 +0000 UTC

Comments

SpaceGoddess76

My thoughts are just suggestions or things I’d do if I was writing this book. You should make this YOUR story and write it how YOU want to write it not how some reader would. So you do you!! You also don’t need to necessarily rewrite this at all. Just some ideas off the top of my head. You can have her go on the run and come across another country with more ruins. Or go on the run and find that there are actual rebels in her country and the nobles just try to suppress the knowledge (this could also work with her & her family being sort of off the grid for the past several years). Or something else entirely.

EmmaLeia

You both have valid points. I'm going to sleep on it and then map out where this may go with her on the run. I have ideas I planned on using later in the story but she is old enough to initiate them now. I don't want to rewrite the whole story but I can at least put it in a better direction going forward.

SpaceGoddess76

This society just doesn’t seem like it should work and I feel like as the book continues, this society is going to be held together with plot armor to make this society out to be evil. I get the feeling you are trying to make this society evil so as she grows up she can be the savior. However you can make her into a Hero even if she is raised in a peaceful and “Light side” civilization. She can still be the Ancient One to save them.

SpaceGoddess76

I have a few things I’m noticed that are starting to bother me too. 1) I’m really shocked she didn’t just kill the Noble and the guards and have her and her parents run away. Honestly I would have run away the very next morning not even giving anyone a chance to rat them out. I mean the parents have grown up in this society and they actually know what punishments are. Even if they didn’t run away then why still allow the noble to take your parents away for “punishment” and do everything the Noble says in this type of civilization? She has Magic and the nobles don’t know that yet. 2) I was always confused why she told Jade about the complex but I was also confused why she told Sky. I mean I understand they fell down that hole but she could have acted like it happens occasionally “searched” around for awhile and played it off to the parents too. Instead she instantly spills her guts to the young child and later when another young child who is know to be a gossip asks she still tells her stuff. She is an adult from Earth who I’m guessing had learned History and should know the awful things people did to commoners throughout history. Yet she spills her guts to children yet not even her parents? 3) How has this society not collapsed already? Just looking throughout Earth’s history most societies like this collapse or rebel or get attacked or any number of things. They don’t work. 4) How is there only 1 noble at this place? With the type of society you keep talking about there should be several nobles with their own people competing to one up each other. You make it sound like these nobles are a tight-knit group yet you also make it sound like every noble is competing against each other. Without Royalty noble societies are usually always trying to one up each other and even with Royalty they tend to do the same thing but they actually have someone who keeps them in check. I mean this is your book and you do you, these are just my thoughts.

EmmaLeia

Can you explain what doesn’t work for you?

Mr. Bigglesworth

First? The level of character stupidity is reaching immersion-breaking proportions here.


More Creators