Onlyreon
Antony444 from patreon
Antony444 patreon

The odds 106 unbetaed

🕑 Added 2023-05-17 10:36:35 +0000 UTC

Comments

Antony444

It doesn't count. The two are distant enough for it to not matter...they are cousins, but this does not count as kinslaying (Sirius being killed by Bellatrix didn't in canon, and they were far closer, both from a genealogy and an emotional perspective).

Alex S

Quick question, does Leo/Galahad breaking the terms of the duel count as an attempted kinslaying for House Black? Or is Alexandra distant enough of a relation to not matter.

Alex S

While all the characters have their biases, remember how by now,: Alexandra, Morag (and the Exiled in general), Amelia Bones, Slughorn, Snape, Flitwick, Crouch Sr and Gellert have all called out Dumbledore making extremely self-serving decisions and expecting people to just accept and be happy with his logic. The entire 1st year of the Odds depicted just how provincial Dumbledore is in his outlook and its consequences.

Guilherme Bezerra

While I certainly enjoyed the chapter as a whole some of its parts were a bit too unreal to me. It is not even the mid battle banter or the lack of coherent strategy by the part of Leo, that was expected, but little things like bringing a dreadnought to the middle of the Thames ( I wouldn't expect the river to be bigger big enough for such a vessel to even be there) or for what reason did dumbledore intervene in the end. It makes no sense what so ever to intervene at the end there. Leo was "destroyed", is still possessed, continues to defy the orders from Dumbledore and adds absolutely nothing to Dumbledore and his faction. Why even do it ? Hell bringing him to St Mungus is a very bad idea. It has been proven to not be enough to stop the very people that want Leo dead, mainly the rest of the Black Family, so what is to stop Bellatrix from going there again ?


More Creators