Onlyreon
C_Mantis from patreon
C_Mantis patreon

Echos Chapter 5

🕑 Added 2023-11-29 19:54:01 +0000 UTC

Comments

Stacey Walsh

I’d love to see one of these from the guy who egged Matt into fighting during the Vassel wars. I remember a passage from his POV during the tier 10 tourney and I’d like to see his shock.

Ploddingpanda

Where did you reread the first book? I recently did a reread but the chapters on Patreon don't go back all the way to the beginning

Donan The Barbarian

I mean a tier 15 can probably destroy even a tier 10 planet if they work on it long enough, after tier 11 the rifts natural recharge rate might cause rift breaks to release matter, essence, and creatures emitting mana faster than a tier 15 could kill everything on the planet and lift matter out of the gravity well. That said I think a tier 15 would still need years (might only be 2 but still years plural) to destroy even a tier 0 planet that hasn't been exposed to essence.

Alex

She can't destroy the planet. The Baroness or the play pen director would stop her. Otherwise.... Without anybody to stop her? It may take some time to destroy the whole planet but it should be possible. It's only T4/5

Story Seeker

For a second I thought Cynthia was the same as the Ice Bond Aster left in charge of her Ice Club at the Acadamy since they have the same name.

Mike Pagnelli

I'm loving these Echo chapters. I'm curious if we'll be seeing anything from/about Camilla? I've always kinda expected her to pop back up at some point in some capacity...

Christopher Hempel

Should actually be ‘parsing’, I believe. Parsing is analyzing something into smaller, more understandable parts.

Bradley Taylor

That sounds amazing

William Beegle IV

You are not alone. I would definitely read more about Cynthia Sinclair.

Havokk

I think either could technically work but you are right I do feel that perusing would make better sense from the context

Jonathan Campbell

Would it be pursuing or perusing? I don't remember the exact sentence and context off hand.

Jonathan Campbell

Also any chance that the Matt and Liz couple who won the bet on their identities might meet them at some point in the future?

Jonathan Robichaux

Do we know who Alfonso is?

Matt H

If anything I can see Aster figuring out some way to have a movie made about Cameron and then having her cast with an ice otter.

Abriel Blauer

Yes

C_Mantis

its a good idea ill add for the book version

Mistfate

Loved it. The cynthia part was do much fun to read, even though I knew what was coming at the end.

Den

Cynthia's echo has been my favourite so far 🤣

Phil

Wait is Darius great great grandfather the other kid Matt arrived at the playpen with?

DumpsterCoffee

Ooooh. "According to movies, the only way out of a challenge rift is to clear it. I have no choice. Quill would have done it, I can, too." So many people are going to die.

DumpsterCoffee

Talk about getting typecast. Her career will never recover from this.

Havokk

@C.Mantis with this reveal of a movie of MLA and the Pather war I keep thinking back to the chapter when MLA picked up their friends on the way to the ascension ceremony. As the Pather movie would have come out fairly recently and MLA teasing their friends and dropping hints you could add in a bit where one of the friends tease them about the movie only to have MLA respond something about being in negotiations to have more made and they will be even more famous over it.

Stormbuilder

Definitely enjoyed the cynthia pov, probably more than any of the other echoes so far

Lorevi Q

Not to be morbid but I'm half expecting his story to tie into the T15 play pen managers and have him die in a rift from overenthusiasm

C_Mantis

Fixed

C_Mantis

No it was a change in timing of her events that I wasnt perfect with

Douglas Sokolowski

Matt didn’t even know about concepts until he saw the advertisements for bottled concepts on another planet and his orphanage was basically a primary school devoted to delving so I don’t think it’s really a stretch for the knowledge to be thought of as rare or lost.

Andrew K

I think a future full side-story focused on Cynthia working on a movie about MLA/QTS would be an excellent way to write in a bunch of hilariously overdramatized/wrong movie scenes in a context-appropriate manner while retaining solid ability to weave in other content to keep the overall result from getting too absurd.

Snugglebadger

She's just watching the feed at the start waiting for the call from her agent, there's no mention of it being the ascension.

Fleetpanda

It is interesting. As a t15 he won’t really need a normally functioning heart and he can have it beat so fast it freaking blurs. His limit is how fast he can make it beat, and at t15 the cap is off

Dion Crump

I think Darius is going to be a tragic statistic. A youth with so much potential but pushed to hard, took the step he should have, took one to many risks because Matt was from Lilly

Neil

I don’t expect him to stay on the path, but Matt’s success will mean a lot of opportunities for those on Lilly to eventually reach T15.

wanderer117

I'm not sure I'm holding out much hope for a nearly T2 on the path making it to T15 after everything goes sideways

Tetrasimplex

Not to mention information suppression is the canonical reason it is less common, as the empire would rather people get closer to tier 15 before possibly wasting large portions of time.

Alex

He was talking normal people prices "particularly since Path discounts would have made them even cheaper." You're right, there is a good chance that the potions are more expensive on Lilly (or maybe they're not, the empire regulates normal people's prices for stuff too, so that higher tiers can't fuck up the ecomony with their greater wealth, Pathers just get discounts on top. It is perfectly possible that sth like the potions has a fixed maximum price empire wide

CringeWorthyStudios

Oh gods that Cynthia PoV was cute. Is it weird that I kinda want to see more of her? I just re-read the chapter and is it just me, or did it seem like Jared knew about Aster being an Ascender?

CringeWorthyStudios

Darius was… hang on. I totally missed that one. 🤣 Also, yeah, getting type cast into one of the most desirable roles out there is just about the only way typecasting could be good.

Stephen Weinberg

I wasn't bashing Aster. But "Scoop" doesn't have the fan bases of Quill and Torch. She also is just one of the 3, not "the MC". Going from the lead to being a very important character is somewhat of a downgrade. Also, yes, this was someone tongue-in-cheek. She is going to have a great career just from this.

Jeff Wells

It's going to be way more expensive on a backwater like Lilly (potentially several orders of magnitude, or even simply unavailable) than it would be on the Capital. Also I'm pretty sure Matt was talking about Pather prices, which are regulated by the Empire. Remember one of the benefits of being on the Path that makes losing external support workable is the significantly lower prices for goods and services, in addition to priority rift access.

C_Mantis

ty

Jeff Wells

Are you kidding? She'll be making movies for the rest of her life off of this. And I don't know what books you've been reading, but Aster isn't a side character. She's one of the three. Cynthia will never play anything less than a co-lead character for the rest of her potentially infinite life.

Pawaidan

I would love more from the last one it was fun. :)

Stephen Weinberg

Lost knowledge happens, absolutely. I expect that most knowledge lost, as it is in our world today, would be lost due to points 2 and 4. But... the idea that knowledge of building your own concept could ever be lost to anything other than point 2 is insane. In fact, it would be more believable if instead of it being a myth/legend it was something that people knew was technically possible but no one knew how to do it because the information was suppressed on the empirenet. Not to mention that everyone would "know" the odds were nearly impossible even if you did know how so most people wouldn't be curious.

Alex

Yeah. People absolutely could do it, but they need to want it, to either leave or save up more. With it being a T4 planet, that means T4 rifts are still somewhat limited and thus probably expensive. But yeah, you could get a loan or leave for a couple years and then return. People like to complain about how expensive it is, but there's always options. It's perfectly fine if you just work hard for a bit. But a lot of people don't feel the need. T4s already live quite a bit longer than earth humans. You can go have a family, live a simple life. Even on earth not all old people wish to live forever. Living forever or even multiple hundred years takes a certain mindset. A lot of people are content with simple.

Stephen Weinberg

Hmm, "a few dozen Tier 4 mana stones". Let's call that 36 even. If each delve averages 7 mana stones, that is 5 delves. If your delving team is 6 people, that is 30 delves. If you delve once per week, that 30 weeks or 7.5 months. You would also need to live at that time, but if you managed to live like a tier 2 or even a tier 3, living expenses would be inconsequential (less than 10% of earnings). The real question to ask is what is the "profit" per delve. We just talked about revenue. We now need to look at costs: 1. rift entrance fees. 2. healing 3. items/weapons consumed 4. taxes (hopefully the taxes accept 1-3 as valid business deductions) Do we have enough information to approximate any of these things? If we assume a 50% cost of revenue (which may be optimistic!), we are talking 16 months of extreme effort for a party of 6 that is financially responsible. Frankly financial irresponsibility likely makes this effectively impossible. If you are in a guild, the guild will likely loan you the money or put you on a forced savings plan. Paying it back is super easy as a tier 5 can collect at least 10x value per delve. If you are not in a guild, someone would lend you the money. If you promised to pay back with a 5x interest rate, you would still pay it back in half the time of saving... assuming you survive tier 5 rifts. Tier 5 rifts introduce enemies with concepts which may be too difficult. Hopefully, more than 1 in 5 people pay back their debt keeping the money lenders in business. Here is where things get interesting. Lilly is a tier 4 planet. That means it is way harder to pay off a loan. The tier 4 rifts would give less reward (since you are a tier 5) and there are no tier 5 rifts for a better reward. This means going off planet is the only way to find people willing to loan you money. Lilly being a tier 4 planet makes it really hard to get to tier 5 without leaving while for literally any other tier, you can get to planet tier + 1 before needing to leave.

SqrlyGrly

I think any movie about Minkalla would either call it an ancient ruin/rift or be limited to audiences over T11

Daniel B

Lost knowledge happens. Perspective was developed in around 1415 about 600 years ago. I tried to teach myself how to draw in perspective, by reading books. How hard could it be? Its been around for 600 years. Books wouldn't lie to me would they? Don't you have to do research to make sure the stuff you write in books is true, before you publish? No. No you do not.

Havokk

In an earlier chapter it was mentioned that there was a movie about the Minkalla run as it guest stared Queen and her secret wolf bond

Jonathan Campbell

Yup, no way in hell Aster would ever let some fire fox act as her!

Yshua

You make solid points, that doesn’t square up.

MikeL

prussing? I think should be perusing.

Havokk

Noticed a typo "Still prussing the information about Aster," should be "Still pursuing the information about Aster,"

The Grey Mage

I like Darius’ Talent, so I hope to see him again. Also, in Cynthia’s part she was watching the Ascension, and then two years later, she’s watching the Ascension.

Alex

I remembered the price slightly wrong. Chapter 257 "While he couldn’t buy a potion for the price that a Tier 4 would have to pay, he was able to look it up. As a Tier 18, he could buy one for just a couple Tier 18 mana stones, which seemed incredibly low. He checked the price that a Tier 4 would have to pay, and saw that it was only a few dozen Tier 4 mana stones. While he hadn’t needed one, he did remember the Unbroken complaining just how pricey they’d been for them, and they’d been professional delvers on the Path. They could absolutely afford a handful of same-Tier mana stones without trouble, particularly since Path discounts would have made them even cheaper."

Stephen Weinberg

At tier 15, boom, you control your hear beat. Can you imagine how powerful he will be at tier 40 with how fast he can run his heart? Maybe he can run two hearts for double the heart rate.

Tom

That was probably the price for those on the path, which is heavily subsidised. If he dropped off at tier 4, he may have missed out on one.

Stephen Weinberg

Err, to be clear, the boy wouldn't know anything I just said. However, the culture would know. The movies and media he consumed would talk of ancient forgotten knowledge from before the Empire's creation. Or it would be secret knowledge learned and then suppressed by a corrupt noble. The very concept of 200 year old knowledge being "forgotten" would not even occur to a citizen of the Empire.

brennon Petersen

Tftc!

Stephen Weinberg

So, I think calling 200 years old a "lost, forgotten technique" is a bit extreme and doesn't fit with the setting. Even mortals understand 200 years isn't long enough to lose such knowledge. Unlike in the real world, they have had advanced technology (including the internet) for thousands of years. Even ignoring that, it is not unreasonable someone can run into someone that old. Maybe it is only your friendly guild recruiter, or "Mr Cortes". But you will meet someone that old in your life if you halfway try. For something to be ancient lost knowledge you need at least one of the following (preferably more than one): 1. A lost language, doesn't exist in the last 40,000 years at least. 2. Destruction or hiding of information. This seems to exist in the Empire. 3. Not having people alive you can just ask... 4. Knowledge that has lost all relevance, at least for a long enough period of time. This is not the case for making your own concept since it is still better to do so. I could see him calling it a technique the evil high tiers hide from mortals, but not a lost technique. Anything known 200 years ago in a stable society would still be known today.

adam1

He'll have is Tier 3 talent and Concept at that point, who knows how that will modify his base talent.

adam1

I think we got a preview of how a Minkalla movie looks when there was a mention of Duke Waters developing powers from delving an ancient ruin for one of his movies.

Alex

Aster made sure that she was gonna be played by somebody competent and people wouldn't replace her with some actress Aster doesn't like who just happens to have more star power or sth in the next shitton of movies that are gonna be made now that she's an Ascender. Smart of her.

adam1

Given that ascenders are super celebrities, they'll do the series and then roll right into a movie. She'll be buried in work for the next 1,000 years.

JauPim

The sponsor might also be keeping their actual tier hidden, since pretending to be weaker than you actually are seems to be an unofficial tradition when you are sponsoring someone for the path.

Alex

Yeah, I reread that a few times, seems like she was watching the ascension, then she was remembering the last time she was waiting for her manager to call her (that's the part where she agreed to play aster) and then it jumps back to the present. It's not really all that clear, it could probably be written a bit better so it's easier to understand

Neil

So Darius' talent seems like it has the potential to be very strange post T15, since his body is under his complete control. Modify his body to have three hearts beating 5000 BPM, win button.

Storyhunter

As an idea for Cynthia's show while the whole thing feels ready to go compared to other programs. The problem for a broadcasting / entertainment company is that audiences are going to want the 3 ascenders together on screen. Using the basic formula that the written story already has with an episode of the academy bonds and mystery. Then flipping to the other pair on missions in space. With the transition between episodes being the video logs sent between them. Would probably work out for a show. A bit of something for everyone there. It's not the full leading role the actor wants but it's the next best thing.

SilasDrekken

Seems like a prime talent for exploitation. He’d almost certainly do better off the path than on it. Get that boy an artificial heart that beats 10x as fast just to produce circulation equal to a normal resting heart and bam, you’ve got a powerhouse.

Serran

The Darius part was interesting and the "ancient and forgotten knowledge" part cracked me up a little. :) The question that I now have is when the cuttoff time for rewards of the sponsors is. And how many people you can sponsor. Is it only 1 person you sponsor on the path at once? Or only one sponsoring every so long timespan? From the Unbrocked it seems that you can sponsor a group. You can't sponsor someone if you left before Tier 5. I think that was mentioned in the message Matt's sponsors send him after he reached Tier 5. The Actress was fun. A little bit more the Diva than she might need to with her Agent though at least it didn't seem like she was completely unreasonable. I am kind of wondering what Tier she is at. She has an Intent so at least Tier 20, most likely more. So the question comes why she would almost faint. Doesn't she have the control of her body to prevent that? And I am also wondering what is in the movies, d*mnit. In the movie ‘When Sun’s and Daughter’s Bleed’ did they insert references to Quill and Torch that are wrong in retrospect? And given that there will be a series about Aster in the Bond Academy what is going to be in there. Bitter Rivalery with the Peacock from the Pather War? Are they getting that Actor as a Guest star? Also how will they mangle the truth? Are the Ice Cream shops that Aster set up going to be Series Aster taking them over because they were bad and running out of Business? Is there going to be a recuring occurence of Aster sneaking out during the night to Delve Rifts since she is secretly still on the Path? And the Rift challenge. If it is in there I doubt it will be 'Aster notes the Rift challenge when she enters, kicks everyone else out and has fun clearing it' I imagine more like: 'Due to the Rift challenge the only option to leave the Rift is to clear it. Aster desperately tries to coordinate a mostly incompetent delving team that is in over their heads but doesn't notice. And she also has to hold back enough that people don't notice that she is so powerful. Complete with Scene of the Delving team desperately fighting and beating a monster while Aster takes the remaining dozen of the same type while making sure they don't notice.' I am always wondering about these movies. Even an Outline would be interesting. EDIT: I don't think they are going to do a Movie of the Minkalea run. Wouldbe interesting though.

Vayash

The ascension was a multi year event of people coming. It was on the news for years about it.

Stephen Weinberg

Poor Cynthia... they might end up cancelling her show to make an Ascender movie where she is just one of the main character instead of the lead. Hopefully she can schedule filming for both.

William Johnson

I believe the detrimental talents flag specifically needs the sponsor to be tier 15, my understanding is that anyone who reached tier 5 on the path can sponsor a new pather regardless of their current tier.

Stephen Weinberg

I was also confused...

Alex

Didn't the potion only cost 25 T4 mana stones? Expensive for a T4 sure, but not ruinously so, especially if said T4 is able to delve T4 rifts (though that was the price Matt looked up in the capital, may he more expensive on other worlds?)

Markus

I laughed when I was reading about Cynthia. Talk about having your fortune made.

Josh Bullock

That's the ascension of Light and Shadow I think!

Jeppe Fiig

Really liked the Cynthia Echo, was a nice touch 😁

Alex

I recently reread the story, so I remembered his name. He was only mentioned for a little while cause he was picked up by Griff from the trainstation at the same time as Matt. He is not mentioned afterwards. They weren't friends or anything.

Alex

Yeah, it's restricted, because if it's common knowledge a lot of people with big egos waste a bunch of time trying and then die young. Forming a concept early is rare and the benefits of waiting usually don't outweigh the risks

Alex

I'm still not sure about what the rules on sponsors are. detrimental talents that get flagged by the planet Ai get a sponsor to check them out, but that sponsor has to have reached T5 on the Path AND be T15+ at the moment. I kinda just assumed that meant all sponsors are T15+

William Johnson

Definitely, I love seeing what the normies think about all these crazy immortals.

William Johnson

Have a good psuedo break, and this was a delight. Especially the Cynthia bit, and I thought other Liz and Matt hit the jackpot.

Azulmar

Cynthia seems to be watching the ascension during the first call and again two years later.

John Balman

Loving how these chapters flush out the world, hoping Darius doesn't bite off more then he can handle, Actress pov was very interesting could tell that the production company had someone in the know preparing for the reveal LoL

Abriel Blauer

If I remember correctly, knowledge about concept is restricted for those below Tier 5. On a planet like Lily (Tier 4) it is safe to assume that pretty much no one knows about it. Matt only learned about it because of Liz.

IWannaBeATiger

Yeah that had me giggling

BurnNote

Both of the these were hilarious.

MinE

His talent might actual make him safer than if he didn't know about Matt and Aster; his heart rate is going to be dangerously high if he is fighting for his life and still riding off the excitement of this experience. P.S I wonder how high his heart rate can go before his increasing physical cultivation can't keep up with the issues brought about by a high heart rate.

adam1

It's good to get the mortal view of all of this. Lost ancient knowledge from 200 years ago, legends of reaching Tier 5 without a potion... it really helps put the story in perspective.

SCDarkSoul

Goddamn. I had zero memory of that. Still, while he never excelled, at least it seems he managed to set up his descendants well off enough. Darius II's excitement is rather infectious here, yet also rather morbid given the previous perspective of the tier 20 overseeing the playpen.

Havokk

Loved this one. Loved seeing the legacy of the person inducted to the playpen the same day as Matt. And Cynthia is just fantastic. Im happy to hear they did a movie based on the vassal war staring Matt Liz and Aster. Cynthia will definitely be type cast for a long time but being type cast to play an ascender would be an incredible career boost especially when said ascender compliments her on her acting.

Bender

Would have been nice if this Darius knew his ancestor knew Matt personally! Also Cynthia....right place. Right time.

Miguel Canarte

i need more, but take your time

william wallace

Damnit. Take your upvote.

Tommy

2 weeks time echo: darius’s funeral was a small affair…. 😭😭😭😭

Walter

Haha this is so good! Love the perspective

Ford

Really thought the Darius bit was going to end with him getting cocky and being killed.

Calista

I really dig these Echos stories. People reacting to the MC's and their accomplishments.

Apiris

I really liked the Cynthia portion

Abriel Blauer

Glad to see I was not the only one remembering him

Anton Selling

The actress part was just so good : )

Derze

This is sweet.

Michael Younger

Darius was the name of the kid Matt joined the Playpen at the same time as. Its a little sad to hear he never really excelled but nice to see his family still kicking around on Lily.

SCDarkSoul

Thanks for the chapter. Couple of rqandoms, but interesting perspectives. Neat to see how the lives of random people get touched by the MCs who have barely or never interacted with them.

James Faulkner

Tftc!

Lucas Johns

Love these echo chapters!!

Teatime42

God I hope Darius doesn't try and pull a Matt. D : Cynthia was adorable, nicely done.

IWannaBeATiger

Lol Cynthia got one of the luckiest breaks imaginable

Bob Bryan

She went to Jared's

Michael McMahon

Tftc


More Creators