Onlyreon
MaeveMcCarthy from patreon
MaeveMcCarthy patreon

Chapters 45-47

🕑 Added 2025-06-18 20:00:08 +0000 UTC

Comments

khora

…this reminds of asking an AI for an answer to a question it doesn’t have enough information on. Instead of asking for more context it formats a response with a lot of big words but no real answer.

Froyo Baggins

Yeah, the dynamic has moved from interesting to disappointing. Without character change and growth, why read. I'm unsubbing.

khora

I think the father being a terrible father makes sense. He never wanted to raise a child, he wanted a vessel to do what he couldn’t. If Lily was a boy he would have just been a means to an end. Actually did he ask for an heir or just for Adriana to be able to have a kid? Either way he was a lost idiot long before Lily was born. Even his wish was dumb; he breaks some rules but won’t break others. I don’t think he even sees himself as a rebel. He wants a purely selfish revenge for his sister’s death, not to go on some just crusade against the current worldview or such nonsense.

FarFromLogic

the father was the one that triggered these events to begin with, his sudden blindness and stupidity (to look the other way whilst his enemies push him towards death because he doesn't want to get their attention on his daughter who already has their attention), it doesn't make sense, he's not around enough to have shown any emotional investment in his daughter to want to hide her so much, he worked with librarians and made some deal to get an heir and now his character has regressed so much, initially his sister was his motivation for his rebellion, now its eluded too that its his reason for his cowardice, I like the way Lily's mother is written in the re-write so much more but the dad, first he breaks her jaw then he tries to cage her, its frustrating and annoying and his character feels less fleshed out and more like a tool to set up some convoluted plot point, but surely that didn't need to be set up by him being an idiot apologies if this was a bit of a rant, I love the way the mother is written this time around and the father was in my opinion pretty good in the original whilst I really disliked the mothers original character in the same way I'm reacting to the dad now, they should be motivated based on their character, ambitions and motives but I feel like in this case its more to move the story in a certain direction, I might be completely wrong and the next reveal might change thigs


More Creators