Cambrian
patreon
Lightning Strikes Twice Ch. 66 (Harry Potter)
🕑 Added 2025-01-22 16:48:24 +0000 UTCA/N: To set expectations for this chapter, I don't subscribe to Evil!Dumbledore theory. Well-meaning but old and sometimes incompetent is where I'm at with Dumbledore.
-x-X-x-
Albus Dumbledore had been around the block a few times, as the kids might say. To borrow another bit of common parlance from the younger generation, he was not used to being ‘thrown for a loop’ so to speak. He was not so egotistical or arrogant to believe he knew everything there was to know about everything, to be fair. But at the same time, he usually liked to think he had his finger on the pulse regarding the things happening in his own backyard.
… The events of the last few days had made it abundantly clear that he did not. No, rather, it was more like the events of the last year if he was truly being honest with himself and self-reflecting. Even if things had certainly escalated massively over the last few days, first with the seeming death of the Dark Lord and then the discovery of his followers all dead in their homes or place of business, the truth was, it had started long before that.
Everything had started when Harry’s name had come out of the Goblet of Fire. Not only had that been beyond Albus’ expectation, but even young Harry’s reaction had been… a little off at the time, if he was being honest. The Headmaster had chalked that up to being in a state of shock, but given everything that had transpired since, Albus had to wonder. Things… were not adding up.
He liked to think he had a fairly good idea of what kind of young man Harry Potter was growing into. Certainly, Albus had put a lot of effort into ensuring the sort of bright, upstanding, and courageous wizard that they would need to face off against Voldemort whenever he began clawing his way back.
That was something Albus had known for a long time now to be a possibility. It wasn’t until after young Tom’s original defeat that he’d heard whispers of the other wizard’s efforts towards achieving immortality, but once he’d begun to research the topic, Albus had encountered incredibly disturbing implications that had in turn morphed into truly horrifying conclusions.
Tom Riddle… had engaged in the heinous and horrible act of creating horcruxes. Not just a horcrux, but multiple horcruxes. One was bad enough. Poor Myrtle… it was a shame that even to this day, the public didn’t quite know what happened to her, but at least between the death of the Basilisk and the destruction of Tom’s Diary, she’d been avenged twofold by Harry.
As soon as he’d found out about Tom’s horcruxes, Albus had begun hunting them. He even had a general idea of where a handful could be found. Only… he wasn’t getting any younger. Defeating Dark Lords was a young man’s game and Albus, for all his power and magic, knew full well that his time was running out. As well, there was the prophecy.
Having been the only one to hear the entirety of Sybill’s True Prophecy, Albus knew better than most to think he could possibly tackle Tom on his own. Sometimes it didn’t matter how much power you had. Sometimes Fate and Destiny had other plans that didn’t involve you.
With that in mind, Albus had done his best to prepare Harry for the trials ahead. But at the same time, he’d also wanted to give the young man as close to a normal Hogwarts experience as possible. Perhaps that had been a mistake. Perhaps Albus would have been better off taking Harry on as his apprentice right off the bat. It wouldn’t have likely surprised that many people if he’d done so. The Boy-Who-Lived, getting direct tutelage from the wizard who dealt with the last major Dark Lord?
It would have fit quite well into the fantasizing minds of the Wizarding World’s populace. Like something right out of a storybook, really. But the real world didn’t work on stories. It didn’t function on fantasy and make-believe.
Albus had only wanted what was best for Harry… and what was best for the world. For the Greater Good, he’d been hoping to walk a thin line between preparing Harry for dealing with Tom once and for all… and having something approximating a normal life with friends and loved ones. Obviously it wasn’t perfect. Mistakes had been made here and there. But Albus had nevertheless had the best of intentions.
Now though? Now the aging Headmaster didn’t know what to think. It had only been three days since the Third Task of the Triwizard Tournament, and Albus was still reeling from the events of that night, as well as what had happened in the days that followed. Here he sat in the Hogwarts Headmaster’s Office, trying fruitlessly and tiredly to make sense of everything.
Tom had made a successful return. He’d subverted them from start to finish, replacing Mad-Eye Moody of all people with a loyal Death Eater who shouldn’t have even still been alive, let alone out of Azkaban. It was perfect, in a way. Albus would never suspect anyone was capable of taking Moody’s place. Not when the retired Auror preached ‘Constant Vigilance!' above all else.
And yet, while Harry hadn’t known it at the time because Bartemius Crouch Junior had dropped the polyjuice when he tried to kidnap the younger wizard… it was what had happened all the same. They’d found the real Moody locked in a magically enlarged trunk in his office after his disappearance was finally noticed, and he’d told them everything that had happened.
From the very beginning, Crouch Jr. was behind everything. From Imperiusing his own father, to putting Harry’s name in the Goblet under a nonexistent fourth school, to charming the Champion’s Cup to teleport the first to touch it to a graveyard in Little Hangleton instead of the Champion’s Stage outside of the hedge maze.
Yes, Albus had suspected almost immediately which graveyard Tom would have brought Harry to, if he’d performed the Dark Ritual that Albus suspected to return himself to full power. He would have needed not just Harry’s blood, but also his own family’s bones. Albus was perhaps one of the only people who knew exactly who the Dark Lord Voldemort really was.
Alas, when he’d gone to the graveyard after the fact to investigate, he hadn’t found much. There’d been remnants of the ritual and potion that had brought Tom back, just as he’d suspected. But… not much else. Almost as though someone had at least partially cleaned the area up. The taste of magic in the graveyard had been palpable all the same, however.
And yet, all of that wasn’t even the half of it. Albus could barely conceive of a situation where Voldemort returning to power was the least of his worries, but that was exactly the situation he found himself in now.
Mostly because… well, Tom’s return had apparently been very short-lived. Seeing Harry appear on the Champion’s Stage with Tom’s corpse had been… eye opening to say the least. Albus still didn’t quite understand what had happened, but he was starting to put together a theory. One that he didn’t like… not one bit.
He had been hunting Tom’s horcruxes for years now. It wasn’t until the Diary that he’d actually managed to get his hands on one though. While he had suspicions about some of the locations, he knew he couldn’t risk exploring them without taking all the necessary precautions first.
Even still, ever since Harry had started at Hogwarts, Albus had begun to wonder about that scar on the younger wizard’s head. That the scar was cursed had been obvious even when Albus held Harry in his arms as a baby. However, a few diagnostic spells at the time had revealed the immense protection that Lily’s sacrifice had availed upon Harry. Knowing even then that Tom’s return was a potentiality, and that trying to cleanse the Curse Scar would also require cleansing Lily’s protection first, Albus had ultimately decided to leave it be.
… Now, that felt like a mistake. A rather large mistake, truth be told. Because if Albus’ newest suspicions were in any way correct, then Harry Potter… was Tom Marvolo Riddle’s last horcrux.
That night, when the Dark Lord had tried to end a young Harry’s life with the Killing Curse, only to have it rebound back in his face and end him instead… he hadn’t just cursed Harry. No, Tom had done something far worse and far more foolish than that. He’d inadvertently used his own death to split his already frayed soul yet again and lodged a fragment of his soul in poor Harry’s head in the process.
If Albus was correct about that, then it stood to reason that Lily’s sacrifice and the protective magic she’d bestowed upon Harry with her death had probably held back the malevolent influence of Tom’s soul fragment all Harry’s life. However, not even the strongest of magics can last forever. And as brilliant as Lily Potter was, Tom Riddle was just as brilliant in his own terrifying way, on top of being far too powerful for his own good.
Albus can’t see any other way around things. Looking at the events of the last year, from Harry’s growing confidence to his performance in a number of avenues… it seemed obvious at this point that Lily’s protection was slowly but surely degrading. Tom’s soul fragment had begun to seep through and… alter Harry’s mind.
Oh, don’t get Albus wrong, he was well aware that Harry was and had always been a powerhouse. The young man was at least on the level of Albus, Gellert, and Tom when it came to his innate magical power. Summoning a Patronus strong enough to hold back a hundred Dementors in only his Third Year had proven that.
However, the one way in which Harry had always differed from Albus and the other two… was ambition. He lacked ambition in a way that Gellert, Tom, and even Albus himself did not. Albus had always admired Harry for that. Even envied him, really. That lack of ambition was what made Harry the perfect counterbalance to Tom and his schemes.
But while Harry’s mother had given her life to help her son get as far as he had without Tom’s influence seeping through, her sacrifice could not last forever. Everything that had happened in the past three days, as well as in the past year, made more sense when viewed through that lens. The soul fragment lodged in Harry’s curse scar was beginning to seep through.
Now to be fair, Albus didn’t think Tom had fully subsumed Harry’s mind yet. In fact, it was possible that the inadvertent horcrux the Dark Lord had made literally couldn’t completely take over Harry’s mind. While Harry’s actions over the past year, now viewed through a different lens, were quite uncharacteristic at times… he also hadn’t been acting like Tom would have in his place.
Saving and healing Cedric Diggory for instance, while an incredible feat of magic, was not something that Tom Marvolo Riddle would have ever even considered doing of his own volition.
No, Harry was still there, mostly. But there was simply no denying Tom’s influence was growing. From all of the sudden getting into politics, to slaying the Dark Lord himself, Harry was coming into his power far, far too fast now. He had always been powerful, but never before did he have the confidence nor the ambition to make the moves he was making now.
But there was still time, as Albus saw it. Tom was almost certainly still alive, of course. Harry might have stopped him from coming back yet again, but the horcruxes meant that the Dark Lord could not be permanently killed. Knowing what he knew, it fell upon Albus to pull things back together, clean up this mess, and right this sinking ship.
One might think that started with confronting Harry and doing whatever possible to remove the horcrux from his head before it could influence his mind further… but that would be ‘jumping the gun’ as the muggles liked to put it. Ah but he did so love their little sayings.
Harry was doing alright for now. Until he started exhibiting darker tendencies, Albus didn’t need to step in just yet. And… the more information Albus could get on the subject of Tom’s other horcruxes, the better equipped he would be to help Harry once and for all. After all, in all of his research, Albus had never come across talk of a Living Horcrux before. It bore further study, to be sure.
In the meantime, if he could get his hands on even one of Tom’s horcruxes, and one that still held a fragment of his soul unlike the Diary, then Albus could study it and figure out how to destroy it while leaving the receptacle intact… unlike the Diary.
That was the main goal at this point, because whatever else Albus thought of his actions, Harry would be a vital force for Good and Light in the Wizarding World in the decades to come if he could be cured of Tom’s corruption. Long after Albus was gone, Harry would hopefully remain to shepherd their people into the right direction.
Fortunately, it wasn’t all bad news. Despite all the nonsense going on right now, despite all the chaos… Tom had faced yet another setback. And even better, Albus knew of two potential locations for the currently weakened Dark Lord’s horcruxes.
Knowing what he knew now about how limited their time was, Albus could no longer put off searching those places, even though the danger was sure to be extreme. Harry was on a timer now after all.
All that the Headmaster had to decide… was which place to search first.
Comments
titan
Inkompetent with a bit of world view. would be my bet. It would fit the general theme of HP when it comes to authority figures. That could also be very easily explained in Universe with the magical world being very 18th/early 19th century. In the muggle world if you want to teach, you learn the subject AND how to teach. Pedagogy is most likely not even a field of study for the magicals. So, by that logic everyone at Hogwarts would at best be a talented amateurs. At worst intentially damaging like Snape (the obvious case or unintentially like Dumbledore.
Alun Lewis
It's funny...I never know where I want to stand on Dumbledore as an antagonistic figure in any HP fanfic. Is it better to have him as some master puppeteer who carefully engineered decades of events to secretly maneuver Tom into being a Dark Lord, who'd raise an army of marked supporters to allow Dumbles to know who is on each side of the fight, then pivot to control thing once Dumbles discovers Magic is stepping in to meddle via the Prophecy? Or should Dumbledore be a well-meaning figure who intentionally takes advantage of a situation to begin slow-rolling some deluded plan to fix the Wizarding World through passive-agressive behaviour that only makes the Light-Dark divide worse? Even better? I'm not even sure I want Harry to clue the old coot in to the future, even if Dumbledore is moments from death via the withering curse on the Gaunt ring or being ripped apart by Inferi. If Dumbledore wants to assume that Harry is being slowly possessed by Tom's soul fragment, why not make his last moments the worst of his long life by making him think he's lost and the Wizarding World will soon be ruled by a tyrant who will reshape the Wizarding World into something Dumbledore would never recognize. The fact that said tyrant is mostly benevolent and will be more than happy to sit back and let competent minds do the heavy lifting once magic is safe? Well....Dumbledore doesn't need to know everything 😉
Justin Uzumaki
Death by withering curse, or death by hundreds of inferni
Mr.LeeII
My belief is that Dumbledore can never come out of a story intact. He is the main antagonist and the wizarding world will never progress forward with him around. Either leads to his death. One he just disappears or sacrifices another follower.
Mr.LeeII
Dumbledore is always is the greater good. He is always the main antagonist. He is always dark. Raising someone to die is dark. It is always a matter of the extent. Some others like to go to the extremes which can be fun. Others take a moderated approach.
Mage
Thissssss!!!! At least SOME of this scene HAS to go into the next chapter! love it
Kasikan
The issue is even in second year people called Harry the heir of Slytherin. They blamed him for people being attacked in the school when it was the basilisk. Fourth year was the whole getting stuck in a tournament as a fourth champion. He never once denied anything or stood up for Harry. Letting people come to their own conclusions which alienated him from everyone and allowed them to harass him constantly without any repercussions. Dumbledore is either complicit in letting these types of things occur or he's grossly incompetent in managing the school he's supposed to be the headmaster of. Take into account that people likely reported problems with Snape and Dumbledore would have either had to completely ignore them or say it's fine for him to stay in his position. None of it paints a good picture of what type of person Dumbledore is.
Nanaya7Nights
In this story, was he aware of Harry's suffering? Because it looks like he just wanted Harry to live a normal life and only NOW suspects that Harry may be a Horcrux. Also, in canon I feel like Dumbledore is a victim of the genre shift. The wise old big good and class of evil students works in children's fantasy books where the end of the world or the great catastrophic event is a hypothetical evil that the children stop. But when the last part of book 4 upped the stakes and killed a student on screen and started amping up from there, the audience started looking at past events in a more grim light. So, it became hard to see Dumbledore as the big good who was ultimately right in his "faith" in Harry when Harry only won due to Voldemort holding the villain ball and Harry's protagonist plot armor. And Snape as Harry's teacher & his abusive family didn't help. Thus giving rise to the dark lord Dumbledore, greater good Dumbledore and delusional Dumbledore stories.
Nanaya7Nights
Honestly, I felt that Dumbledore was just tired and welcomed the idea of dying. So, in my ideal version of events Harry would reveal part of the truth to him (He is from the future and is trying to stop the end of the world by creating magitech so that magical and the mundane humans can coexist) and offer to heal him, but Dumbledore rejects it saying that with Voldemort gone he can die in peace leaving the world in the hands of the next generation.
JO LP
I think any of these options would result in his death anyway. Since he now suspects Harry is Tom it's unlikely he would involve him in the search for the Horcrux and since he likes to play his cards close to his chest he would likely go alone to the cave therefore he would die there with no one to protect him from the inferi. And without Snape the ring's curse would kill him faster.
JO LP
Indeed. This level of delusion is just as bad as if he was outright evil. The faster he is gone, the better.
jp9901
Either way is a death trap. The ring will curse him with either slowly and the FAKE locket is in a basin filled with nightmare-enducing juice. Either way, he's screwed
Captain Hair
Plot twist: Dumbledore gets cursed, and brings Harry into a meeting to start prepping him for the horcrux hunt and sacrificing himself. Harry takes one look at his hand, and goes "You stupid moron, you just HAD to go for the ring early." Dumbledore: "What?" Harry: "Sigh. Let me fix this." *Fixes Dumbledore* Dumbledore, looking at his fixed hand, then Harry: "How?" Harry: "You thought I was becoming Tom, didn't you?" Dumbledore nods dumbly. Harry: "I'm not being possessed you idiot, I'm from the future. I came back from the apocalypse to fix the shit you and everyone else in The Wizarding World ignored. I'll give you full details later, but it boils down to the inaction of wizards led to the end of the world and the death of magic. I'm not going to let it happen."
Kasikan
Having him suffer and know he's dying is just icing on the cake there. Albus clearly deserves some hellish torture before he gets his send off for all the crap he's pulled over the years.
Kasikan
Albus has to be one of the most delusional people to have ever lived. His preparing Harry was to have the Dursley's beat him down horribly, then have Snape berate him constantly, then finally have the entire school treat him like shit endlessly. If there's a guide book on how to make someone suicidal or go into a murderous rage, Dumbledore should be counted as a massive source for it. He's done just about everything to lead Harry to his own death or to want to kill everyone in the world. From the shit at the hands of muggles to magicals, there really isn't a group that would avoid his kill list.
Nanaya7Nights
I guess people picking option one like me are doing so hoping that Albus gets himself cursed with the withering curse, so Harry wouldn't have to kill him or deal with him for too long.
